Inside the Song

Inside "I Can't Help It": The Genius Behind the Song

"I Can't Help It" might be the most sophisticated song on Off the Wall, and the reason I say might is that nothing about it sounds sophisticated. It sounds smooth. It sounds easy. There's an enormous amount going on harmonically and none of it ✋ raises its hand.

Carlos Rodgarman and Humberto Gatica at the mixing console
With Humberto Gatica during the Dolby Atmos sessions for the Michael Jackson catalogue.

I spent months inside this catalogue remixing it in Dolby Atmos with Humberto Gatica, which means I got to hear these songs one element at a time. That's a strange privilege. Most records tell you what you already suspected. This one kept handing me things I had never noticed in forty years of loving it.

So let me show you a few of them.

It's a Stevie Wonder song

Portrait of Susaye Greene
Susaye Greene, who wrote "I Can't Help It" with Stevie Wonder.

Stevie wrote it with Susaye Greene, and then the Quincy team got hold of it. Once you know that, you can't un-know it. The voicings, the way the harmony slides around, that particular warmth: it's all Stevie, running underneath a pop production that never lets any of it get in the way.

Johnny Mandel did the string arrangement. We will get there, because the strings are the part almost nobody has really heard.

Look at the verse, all my musician nerds out there

We're in A flat. Your ear is expecting a two-five-one, the move it has heard ten thousand times.

It doesn't come. Instead of the E flat there's an A. A tritone substitution. And not a plain one either, because it's carrying a sharp eleventh on top of it, which on paper is a spiky, jazzy, difficult chord that has no business in a pop record.

Two staves in A flat major: the expected ii-V-I, and the ii-subV-I with an A7 sharp eleven in place of the E flat seven 1 · What your ear expects: ii · V · I B m 7 E 7 A 2 · What actually happens: ii · subV · I B m 7 A 7 11 ♯11 A
The same two bars, twice. Above, the cadence your ear is waiting for. Below, what the record actually plays.

Listen to it, though. It's gorgeous.

Here's why it works, and this is the part I love: Michael sings the sharp eleventh. The strangest note in the whole chord isn't hidden away inside a keyboard voicing where you can politely ignore it. It's up there in the lead vocal, and he delivers it like it's the most obvious note in the world. When the melody owns the tension, your ear stops filing it as tension and starts filing it as colour.

The turnaround that never lets you sit down

Now listen to the end of the verse. The phrase wants to land, and it's not allowed to.

What happens instead is small and perfect. A major seventh chord turns into a dominant seventh, and that one alteration is enough to spin you straight back to the top of the verse.

You keep getting denied the ending you were waiting for, and it happens so gracefully that you never notice. The song simply never sits down.

Nobody plays anything

Solo the drums for a second. Listen to what JR Robinson does on that snare. He is barely touching it. Barely! And that groove never moves, never asks for your attention, never once tries to be the interesting thing in the room. Paulinho da Costa is right there beside him doing the same job with the percussion, all his signature colours, none of them showing off.

Nothing in that rhythm section is trying to make Michael sing differently. It holds the story up and stays out of the way.

Then look at what Greg Phillinganes is doing on keys, because this one you can steal tonight. His voicings leave out the root. He plays open forms instead. So the harmony stays airy and slightly undecided, the bass never gets crowded, and all those ninths and thirteenths have somewhere to sit. They breathe because nobody stacked a root underneath them.

An A flat major ninth chord written twice, with and without its root, over an A flat in the bass with the root A 9 no root A 9
The same chord, twice. The root in gold is the note he leaves out — and the bass already has it covered.

The strings, with mutes

Portrait of Johnny Mandel
Johnny Mandel, who wrote the string arrangement.

Now the strings come in, and this is the jewel.

They're played with sordino. Not the bright, glossy string sound you expect on a record like this, but something softer and slightly veiled. In the second half of the verse they open into harmony, and there's a leading line moving from the major seventh down to the seventh that makes the whole passage feel like it couldn't have gone any other way.

Listen to that line on its own once. Then listen to the verse again. You're never going to hear it the same way.

Did you catch the chorus?

In the chorus the strings do something completely different. Violins, violas, cello, all up in the top of their range, violins divisi, still muted. It's a Frank Sinatra moment sitting inside a 1979 pop record.

You have heard this chorus a thousand times. Go back to it knowing the strings are doing that. Different chorus.

What I could finally do in Atmos

The RG Studio control room, with height speakers mounted on the ceiling
The room where the remix happened. The speakers on the ceiling are the ones stereo never had.

The arrangement keeps sneaking new colours in, a little at a time. A flute line in the chorus that later becomes a brass section. A new keyboard hook in the second verse. A horn line in the third verse, which, by the way, has no lyrics at all.

In Atmos I put that flute line slightly behind you and slightly above. The strings aren't very wide, so sending the flute back and up buys depth instead of width, and the two stop fighting over the same piece of the room. The Rhodes and the keyboards sit from the shoulders forward. Michael stays in the centre, where he always was.

None of that's invention. The arrangement was describing those relationships the whole time. Stereo just never had the room to show them.

The chorus goes home and it doesn't

One more harmonic thing, because it explains why the song feels like it never stops moving.

The chorus goes to the four, then to the five. The five is a promise. It tells your ear the tonic is coming.

It doesn't come. We land on the relative minor, F minor, and the loop starts over. The whole song is built on a cycle that's never allowed to close, which is why four minutes in you still feel like you're somewhere in the middle of it.

Why it sounds easy

Sharp elevenths, major ninths, thirteenths, tritone substitutions: all of it can live inside a pop record and feel like it belongs there. The trick isn't simplifying any of it. The trick is that everybody plays less than they could.

The drums stay put. The bass stays put. The keys drop the root. The strings put mutes on. The horns show up late and leave early. Nobody does anybody else's job, and because there's space between all of it, you can actually hear the strings and the horns and the Rhodes talking to each other.

Put it on again tonight and listen for that conversation. The song isn't smooth because it's simple. It's smooth because a room full of extraordinary players all decided to hold back.

Full transcript
  1. 0:00 Hi, Carlos Rodgarman here, and today I'm here to talk about "I Can't Help It", one of my favorite songs from "Off the Wall".
  2. 0:08 This might be actually the most sophisticated song in my opinion of the "Off the Wall" album.
  3. 0:13 It just doesn't feel complicated, harmonically it's super interesting, there's so much going on,
  4. 0:19 but it just feels like smooth, very easy to the ear, so to speak.
  5. 0:23 I want to go inside the song a little bit and show you some gems that are in this arrangement, this production.
  6. 0:28 How something elaborate and complicated doesn't sound jazzy, it just sounds pop and easy to the ear.
  7. 0:34 That's the genius part of it.
  8. 0:36 This is a Stevie Wonder song that he wrote together with Susaye Greene, and it was transformed by the Quincy team, right?
  9. 0:44 I believe they had Johnny Mandel doing an incredible string arrangement that we'll hear here.
  10. 0:50 And it's one of my favorite jewels because it's one of those that, you know the song, but until you hear what was happening there,
  11. 0:57 it's going to surprise you.
  12. 0:59 Once you know it's Stevie Wonder in case you didn't know, you're going to hear it again with different ears and you're going to hear Stevie's influence.
  13. 1:05 It's basically the verse with a very interesting harmony and then the chorus and it's just a cycle that repeats
  14. 1:12 and it keeps bringing new elements, bringing new colors and it just keeps the listener engaged at all times.
  15. 1:18 It all starts with this progression that is just beautiful by itself.
  16. 1:27 Already right there, harmonically there's so much going on and it just feels so easy.
  17. 1:44 But it's actually a very interesting substitution and I'll show you what I mean.
  18. 1:48 The beautiful part of this, look at the verse for all my musician nerds out there.
  19. 1:53 We're an A-flat major, right? So instead of having the five-two-one,
  20. 2:03 we have the tritone substitution. Instead of the E-flat we have the A, but look at this sound.
  21. 2:19 So what's happening there is that it's actually the tritone with the sharp 11, right?
  22. 2:24 And Michael even sings this note, the sharp 11.
  23. 2:34 It's the continuity to it, right? So listen one more time.
  24. 2:47 We can see how Michael is so intimate, right? Let's listen to his delivery.
  25. 2:53 Looking in my mirror, took me by surprise, I can't help but see you.
  26. 3:07 Let's check out his performance, all his mic.
  27. 3:12 Super intimate.
  28. 3:14 Looking in my mirror, took me by surprise, I can't help but see you.
  29. 3:28 Running often through my mind, helpless like a baby.
  30. 3:38 And instead of resolving, right, we're going to do this turnaround.
  31. 3:52 So listen to that, how genius, how it connects.
  32. 3:58 This is a major seven. It turns it into a dominant seven to go back to the verse.
  33. 4:08 And now we resolve to go to the chorus.
  34. 4:32 Without his voice.
  35. 4:38 Listen the genius of JR on the drums, how he's just like barely caressing the snare.
  36. 4:49 It's just so, so amazing.
  37. 5:08 Then you have obviously, Palunio da Costa with signature sounds.
  38. 5:19 Let me open it with the drums.
  39. 5:38 The groove just stays there. It's a bit that it's just not distracting.
  40. 5:54 It's not pushing Michael to sing any other way. It's just supporting the whole storyline.
  41. 6:00 Now the beautiful thing about this, if you see how the first loop around starts with the
  42. 6:06 notes, right? Then we bring this dreamy key words, so beautiful.
  43. 6:36 Chorus.
  44. 6:49 Greg uses actually voicings on the keyboard that don't have the root instead of playing.
  45. 6:56 He actually uses an open chord form.
  46. 7:06 The genius of bringing new elements in pieces little by little with subtle color
  47. 7:14 additions. Look at this addition we have here in the chorus.
  48. 7:31 In Atmos we actually place that flute line that then is going to turn into a brass section
  49. 7:38 later in the song. It's placed like a little bit behind and up elevated a little bit so that it
  50. 7:45 creates these depths with the strings that are not so wide. There's the the roots and the keywords
  51. 7:50 that are here shoulder to front, right? Covering this area and then Michael obviously in the center.
  52. 7:56 It's basically a AB form that keeps repeating verse chorus verse chorus, right? When we go into
  53. 8:02 the second verse we have this new line on the keyword that it's like another hook to it.
  54. 8:16 Let me mute Michael for a second. I'm sorry Michael don't get mad.
  55. 8:31 Now another element this is one of the jewels that I want to show you guys is together with this
  56. 8:37 the strings come in. The strings are beautifully played arranged by Johnny Mandel. They're
  57. 8:45 beautifully executed they're all with mutes with sordino. Listen to this.
  58. 8:58 We're on the verse.
  59. 9:03 Second half of the verse now we open to harmony.
  60. 9:25 Notice that beautiful leading line how it goes from the seventh major seventh to the seventh.
  61. 9:33 I'll play it now in the context of the vocals so now you're going to hear
  62. 9:37 this in a different way that you have before hopefully.
  63. 10:00 Now in the chorus we go to a string moment that to me is
  64. 10:03 just like a Frank Sinatra moment. Listen to this on the chorus.
  65. 10:13 All the violins violas cello all up there divisives on the violins with the mutes
  66. 10:19 amazing beautiful gorgeous color.
  67. 10:41 Let me show you now the chorus that you've heard a million times
  68. 10:44 but now that you know what's happening on the strings.
  69. 11:10 Did you guys catch that? I mean that's Michael but it's just so steamy when he does that.
  70. 11:33 It just feels so good we don't even have lyrics on this third verse. Listen to that.
  71. 11:40 Now in this verse we're adding another color to the arrangement. Look at this horn line.
  72. 12:10 I'll open it with the string so you see the arrangement.
  73. 12:40 How genius all these complicated tensions that could sound very jazzy sharp 11s major 9s
  74. 12:52 13s etc and it just sounds so smooth so like it belongs. The secret to this is really the
  75. 12:58 restraint in everybody. The drums on the bass, the greg fillings on the keys how everything is
  76. 13:05 just opening up but it's just staying there giving enough space. I'll show you just the rhythm
  77. 13:10 section percussion based on the here synths the keyboards.
  78. 13:33 Like the chorus the harmony of the chorus is so cool. On the whole loop it's going to be
  79. 13:39 the four to the five when we're going to resolve we don't go to the tonic we go to the minor so
  80. 13:43 it keeps this cycle going. Instead of going right we stay back to the to the relative to the F minor.
  81. 14:09 Next time you listen to "I Can't Help It" I really want you to pay attention to all these details.
  82. 14:14 You're going to hear the song in a whole different way. Hopefully you're going to have a different
  83. 14:17 insight and a different ear when you listen to this song. Listen to all these elements how they
  84. 14:21 talk to each other how nobody is taking over anybody's job how there's so much space the
  85. 14:27 dialogue between the strings the horns the roads everybody has their space. What song is your
  86. 14:33 favorite from off the wall? For me it's hard to choose always but this is definitely one of them.
  87. 14:38 But what other songs do you want from other albums or what's your favorite that I should
  88. 14:43 break down next? Let me know and don't forget to like and subscribe. See you in the next one!