Inside the Song

Inside "Earth Song": The Anatomy of an Anthem

How does a pop song end up with the magnitude of a film?

"Earth Song", from HIStory, is the record where that question has a real answer. I had the privilege of mixing it in Dolby Atmos with Humberto Gatica, and opening these multitracks you find out that it isn't a big chorus with a big arrangement behind it. It's architecture. Every element arrives at the exact moment the story needs it, and not one of them arrives early.

It also asks a question that is still current, unfortunately, and I have a feeling it's going to stay current for some time. So let's look at how Michael made the Earth the main character of the movie.

A song that took seven years to arrive

He wrote it in a hotel room in Vienna, on the first of June 1988, in the middle of the Bad tour. There are demos of that early version floating around. It didn't come out until 1995, on HIStory, seven years later.

The video, directed by Nick Brandt, made as much of an impact as the record did, and it tells the story backwards. It opens on the destruction, on everything we've done to the planet, and as the song grows it moves into the healing, until nature is restored. The music does the same thing in the same order, and that is the whole point.

It shares a shape with the Man in the Mirror breakdown: a very intimate beginning that ends in an explosion of choir, the world singing together. What changes is how it gets there.

The harmony stays simple on purpose

We're in A flat minor. The piano motif comes in first, and it carries the harmonic idea of the whole verse before Michael has sung a note.

Here's the trick: harmonically the song stays simple, and all the complexity goes into the layers and the orchestration as it grows. But there's always a little something inside that simplicity. We go one to four, and the four is major, not minor. In a minor key the fourth degree should be minor. This one isn't.

Two staves in A flat minor: the minor fourth the key asks for, and the major fourth the song plays, with its third raised to F natural 1 · what the key asks for A m D m 2 · what you hear A m D ♮6
The fourth degree in A flat minor, as the key writes it and as the song plays it. One note moves, and the mode changes with it.

That's a Dorian parallel: the same chord with its third raised, which opens the colour up without leaving the key. Then it goes to the five, and the five is embedded in the riff itself. Three chords. That's the harmonic engine of a record that ends up sounding like a film score.

The first verse gives you nothing to hold on to

Michael, and a piano. That's it.

The performance is completely stripped down, and it has to be, because what the verse is describing is the brokenness of the world. He shows the emotion and the arrangement gets out of the way. Nothing holds the floor up, so you lean in.

Then the pre-chorus makes its move. It goes to the four again, but this time to the minor one, the one that actually belongs to the key. And leaning on that chord, the song touches the relative major for a second. A window opens, light comes in, and it closes again. The whole harmonic argument of the song is right there: the same degree, told two different ways.

The first chorus still has no drums

Carlos Rodgarman and Humberto Gatica in the studio
With Humberto Gatica, mixing the Michael Jackson catalogue in Dolby Atmos.

The main line arrives, the one everybody remembers, and there are still no drums. There's the bass, and there's a tambourine, which in Atmos I placed slightly elevated, above the plane of everything else.

That single decision changes the room. The keyboards and the pads are already building landscapes that move from the shoulders to the front, and lifting the tambourine out of that plane gives the chorus height before it has any weight. Michael stays in front. Always in front, in every section, no matter how big it gets around him.

The guitar answers him

The second verse brings in a new guest: the guitar. You've heard that line a million times without ever separating it from the record, and what it's doing is answering Michael, phrase for phrase, in the gaps he leaves. It isn't accompaniment. It's a second voice in the conversation, and it brings a new colour into a song that so far has only had piano and pads.

Later, in the choruses, another guitar comes in strumming, and almost nobody notices it. It isn't playing harmony. It's keeping time. It behaves like percussion in a section that, at that point, still doesn't have enough of it.

The orchestra you've never really heard

Portrait of David Foster
David Foster, who co-produced the record with Michael Jackson and Bill Bottrell. Photo: Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Here's the gem. Behind everything, there is a full orchestral arrangement that is spectacular, and it's tucked so far into the mix that most people have never consciously heard it.

That's how David Foster and Bill Bottrell designed it with Michael, and it works: the strings aren't there to be admired, they're there to push. Solo them and you hear a piece of writing that would carry a film. Put them back and you don't hear strings at all. You just feel the song getting bigger.

Separating those elements is the argument for doing this work in immersive. Not spectacle. Recovering musical information that was on the tape the whole time.

His foot on the floor

Portrait of Steve Ferrone
Steve Ferrone, whose acoustic drums are the ones that made the record. Photo: Davidwbaker, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Solo Michael right before the chorus where the drums come in, and you catch something that isn't in any arrangement sheet: his foot on the floor, on the clap, setting up the entrance.

He's counting the band in with his body, and it stayed on the tape. That's the record telling you the drums are about to arrive one bar before they do.

And they arrive properly. Steve Ferrone played them, and the story of how they got there is worth knowing: Michael wanted electronic drums, Ferrone made a deal to cut one demo each way, and when the acoustic version came back Michael started dancing across the room. He was right to. Those drums are half the scale of everything that comes after them.

The bridge goes down, not up

A song this size is expected to keep climbing. This one does the opposite.

For the bridge the energy comes down: piano and strings, holding the whole thing on very little. And behind it there's a sampled synth choir pad, a voice texture that isn't singing anything, sitting there to keep the space warm while the arrangement empties out.

It's the same lesson as the intro. If you want the ending to feel enormous, you have to be willing to give up the floor one more time before you get there.

One whole step up

The best way to elevate a song is still the oldest one. Key change.

Straight up a whole step, direct, no preparation, into B flat minor. No pivot chord, no ramp: the song simply stands somewhere higher and keeps going. It's regularly voted one of the great key changes in pop, and the reason it works is everything that came before it. Five minutes of restraint is what buys you a whole step.

And on the way out, the turnaround changes too. Instead of just sitting on the five the way it did all song, it does something else on the way back. Small detail. It's what keeps the ending from feeling like a loop.

The choir, and the octave underneath

The choir is Andraé Crouch's, and what he and Michael are doing in the climax is call and response. He shouts, they answer. He shouts again, they answer again. Nobody is singing a part: two forces are talking to each other, and that's why the ending sounds like a crowd instead of a production.

Underneath all of it, the bass has a sub-octave mixed in, so every note is doubled an octave lower than you think you're hearing. Guy Pratt played it, and that low octave is what keeps a section this loud from turning thin.

Listen to Michael's delivery across the whole record. He started as intimately as it's possible to start. By this point he's screaming, and it doesn't sound like effort. It sounds like conviction, which is a much harder thing to record.

It ends on a question

Now, this part is my personal interpretation.

The song ends on the dominant chord, without resolving. It hangs there, up in the air, and the record stops.

Two staves in B flat minor: the dominant resolving to the tonic chord, and the same dominant followed by a rest with a fermata 1 · the resolution you expect F 7 B m 2 · what the song does F 7
The dominant of B flat minor, and the tonic chord that never comes.

For me that's the whole song saying one last thing: this is an open question. How do we resolve it? It's up to us. Musically it's genius, because the harmony refuses to give you the comfort the arrangement has spent the whole record building. You don't get closure. You get homework.

What to take from it

Magnitude isn't volume, and it isn't more instruments.

It's a simple harmony you can trust, a mode borrowed for one chord so the simple thing never gets boring, and an arrangement that adds one element at a time in the exact order the story needs. It's an orchestra willing to be invisible, a drummer willing to be argued with, and a singer whose foot on the floor made the final mix.

And it's the confidence to end on a chord that doesn't resolve, because the question the song is asking hasn't been resolved either.

Full transcript
  1. 0:00 How can you have a pop song have the magnitude of a movie?
  2. 0:04 This is a song that actually raises a question that is still current today unfortunately and I have a feeling it's going to be current for some time.
  3. 0:12 In this song, let's just see how Michael had Earth be the main character of this movie.
  4. 0:17 Hi, I'm Carlos Rodgarman and today we're going to go inside Earth Song.
  5. 0:22 Michael Jackson song that I had the privilege of mixing in Dolby Atmos with Humberto Gatica.
  6. 0:28 As you may know, we've been remixing the whole pretty much whole catalog of Michael Jackson into Dolby Atmos and having access to this incredible music, I think it's worth exploring a little bit
  7. 0:39 And getting inside of it.
  8. 0:41 This is a song that has a long history actually because I believe it was first written around 1988 during the Bad tour and there's actually some demos floating around of this early version that
  9. 0:52 Michael did, but then it got released in 1995 on the album HIStory.
  10. 0:57 I still remember today the video that it really made as much an impact as the song itself.
  11. 1:04 It really had an incredible message.
  12. 1:06 This has a similar dynamic to the other song that we analyzed in another episode, Man in the Mirror, in how they develop things from a very intimate beginning to an explosion of a choir
  13. 1:18 And it's just the world is singing together.
  14. 1:20 This song keeps bringing the listener as a witness to the story.
  15. 1:24 The video was beautifully done and it actually has a reverse kind of storyline.
  16. 1:29 So we start from all the destruction, all that we've done to the Earth, right?
  17. 1:33 And then it starts from showing all the brokenness and as we progress in the song and the song grows, we actually go into the healing and we start to see how nature everything gets restored.
  18. 1:44 It's a beautiful concept of a song and beautiful concept of a video.
  19. 1:49 In the intro we have as we all know this effects and we start on this very dreamy kind of ambience.
  20. 2:10 We're going to bring the piano motif that is going to bring us the first harmonic ideas of the of the verse.
  21. 2:18 The trick in this song is that harmonically it just stays kind of simple and the complexity starts on the layers and the orchestration as we grow.
  22. 2:27 But always there's like a little something to that simple, right?
  23. 2:30 We're in A flat minor, right?
  24. 2:34 With the riff that we remember from the intro.
  25. 2:50 Here in the verse there's something interesting happening.
  26. 2:52 This is for my harmony friends.
  27. 2:54 We're in A flat minor.
  28. 2:56 We go one four, but the four is major not minor.
  29. 3:00 So we're doing a parallel from what it should be right to a Dorian parallel.
  30. 3:09 And then we go to the fifth.
  31. 3:14 It's embedded in the riff.
  32. 3:30 We can see how intimate Michael singing on the first verse.
  33. 3:36 What about sunrise? What about rain with a piano?
  34. 3:43 What about all the things that you said we were gain?
  35. 3:50 What about and So you see how we're stripped down completely.
  36. 3:59 It's just Michael. He shows his emotion, the brokenness of the world that we're seeing.
  37. 4:04 What are we doing to it?
  38. 4:05 On the pre-chorus, we do a shift.
  39. 4:07 We go to the four, right?
  40. 4:09 But we go actually to the minor, which is what it what it belongs in the key.
  41. 4:13 So, we go we're we're going for the major relative for a second, right?
  42. 4:38 And then we go into the main chorus, the main line, right?
  43. 4:41 That keeps repeating and evolving.
  44. 4:44 We all remember this So
  45. 4:57 The first chorus we still have no drums.
  46. 4:59 We have the bass.
  47. 5:00 We have just a tambourine that actually in Atmos we placed it a little bit elevated.
  48. 5:05 We're creating some really in amazing landscapes between the keyboards and the pads.
  49. 5:10 How it all interacts from the shoulders to the front.
  50. 5:13 Michael in the front always.
  51. 5:15 For the second verse we have a new special guest which is the guitar.
  52. 5:19 It's this. You've heard it a million times, right?
  53. 5:26 And then it answers Michael what about all the peace that you only So
  54. 5:46 We can see in the context of the production and the mix how that guitar plays that answer to Michael in the second verse.
  55. 5:53 So it brings this new What have we done to the world?
  56. 6:02 Look what we've done.
  57. 6:07 So for this, we start to build up.
  58. 6:09 The drums are about to come in.
  59. 6:10 Look at the strings in the orchestra.
  60. 6:12 There's actually another gem.
  61. 6:14 It's how the orchestra arrangement is behind.
  62. 6:17 It's very tucked into the mix.
  63. 6:19 That's how they designed it and it works.
  64. 6:22 But I want to show you guys how the orchestration is behind this.
  65. 6:25 It's And
  66. 6:41 Then we go into the chorus.
  67. 6:43 Full power coming in.
  68. 6:48 Did you catch that one?
  69. 6:50 Let me solo Michael right before the chorus.
  70. 6:57 You see his foot on the floor on the clap to get the setup for the for the drums.
  71. 7:02 I'll play it one more time.
  72. 7:07 In context. We have the incredible drums.
  73. 7:18 Look at this. That's how they sound.
  74. 7:31 Another element that not everybody is aware of is this strum guitar that comes in the choruses and it just keeps it keeps a it almost acts like a Starts
  75. 7:44 Strumming, right? I'll bring it with the Let
  76. 7:58 Me show you the intensity of the orchestra.
  77. 8:00 How we start to grow in this second chorus.
  78. 8:21 Now we bring it down for the bridge.
  79. 8:24 Instead of coming up energy, we bring it down.
  80. 8:27 Look at the piano with the strings.
  81. 8:30 I'll play you the piano and the So,
  82. 8:47 Behind we have a sampled synth choir voice pad.
  83. 8:51 Listen to this. Let's
  84. 9:07 Hear it in context.
  85. 9:19 What's one of the best ways to elevate a song?
  86. 9:22 Key change. Of course, modulation.
  87. 9:24 In this case, we go straight a whole step up, right?
  88. 9:27 We're here and
  89. 9:40 Then direct modulation. With
  90. 9:55 This epic ending, we have a different turnaround.
  91. 9:57 When we go to the five, we have a different turnaround.
  92. 10:00 Instead of just staying on the five, right?
  93. 10:05 It does this thing.
  94. 10:27 By this time we have the guitars.
  95. 10:30 I'll show you. We're full on.
  96. 10:57 Look at how hard he's banging on the WHAT ABOUT YESTERDAY?
  97. 11:05 What about the season?
  98. 11:08 Obviously, we have the choir.
  99. 11:10 We have to hear the choir with him.
  100. 11:17 What about us? In context with everything.
  101. 11:37 The piano is just going full on.
  102. 11:39 Let me solo the piano so you can see.
  103. 11:49 But that pulsing is supporting this whole orchestration.
  104. 11:52 Let me show you.
  105. 11:53 Amazing epic arrangement. In
  106. 12:11 The context of everything, I'm going to bring it up more than what it is on the on the actual mix so you can hear it a little bit better.
  107. 12:37 To Michael's delivery. He started so intimate in the beginning, right?
  108. 12:42 The in the video.
  109. 12:44 Now we're in the healing process of Earth and all this humongous power that we can all pull together to heal the planet.
  110. 12:51 Look at his delivery.
  111. 12:54 WHAT ABOUT THE COMING MAN?
  112. 12:58 CAN WE SET HIM FREE?
  113. 13:01 WHAT ABOUT CHILDREN? The bass has this sub-octaver, right?
  114. 13:12 So, we have this very low octave mixed in the sound.
  115. 13:25 This, this is my personal interpretation.
  116. 13:27 We're ending the song on the dominant chord without resolving.
  117. 13:31 So, for me, it's a way of saying it's an open question.
  118. 13:34 It's up to us, right?
  119. 13:36 How do we resolve this?
  120. 13:37 Musically, it's genius. He's just living it up in the air.
  121. 13:50 It's up to us.
  122. 13:54 I'm reading your comments and your requests and you guys are requesting some really interesting songs.
  123. 13:59 So, I'm going to start recording some of those very, very soon.
  124. 14:02 Don't forget to like and subscribe to stay tuned for the